Furniture Prep – How to Fix a Broken Foot

Hello, friends

This is a quick post just to show you how I fixed the broken foot of this cedar chest I painted a couple of weeks ago.

I received several comments here and on my social media pages, asking me how I had fixed the broken foot, after all, it was not just a bad scratch. A big chunk of it was missing, which is a relatively common problem to find in old furniture.

Square broken foot

I have to admit that, before this chest, I had passed up some gorgeous pieces of furniture that were selling for a bargain, just because I didn’t know how I would solve this problem in a decent way. Then I read a couple of articles of people rebuilding old furniture ornate appliques (Thanks YouTube!) and it just occurred to me I could do the same thing with any missing part of a piece of furniture, as long as there was another identical part in the same piece that I could use to build a mold.

I searched a few options of materials online and ended up choosing silicon putty to make my mold.

Below is my video tutorial showing step by step to make this repair. I also made a video of the process, which I think you will find helpful.

Here are all the supplies I needed to rebuild this foot. I’m leaving some affiliate links* here in case you want to purchase them online.

I started by making my mold with EasyMold Silicone Putty. I chose this particular brand because it was pretty easy to use, but there are several other options available.

I mixed equal parts of the purple and white components until both colors blended completely. Screen Shot 2018-09-09 at 10.01.29 AM

When my mix was ready,  I wrapped it around one of the good feet that I wanted to replicate.Screen Shot 2018-09-09 at 10.11.54 AM

This putty takes about 25 minutes to cure. After that time, I just carefully removed it with my hands and my mold was ready.

Next, I prepared a good amount of Bondo wood filler and inserted it into my mold. You have to work pretty quickly because the Bondo mix starts drying in less than a minute.Screen Shot 2018-09-09 at 10.14.29 AM

I poured my Bondo mix into my mold, then attached it firmly to the foot, holding it with painters tape.Screen Shot 2018-09-09 at 10.43.48 AM I waited until the next day to remove it, to give the Bondo enough time to dry completely.

I detached the mold, then glued the newly built part to the broken foot.Screen Shot 2018-09-09 at 10.16.40 AM

To be on the safe side, I clamped them tightly and waited 24 hours for the glue to dry so I could start sanding.

Screen Shot 2018-09-09 at 10.21.20 AM

Then it was time to sand it to the shape I wanted. The Bondo wood filler dries as hard as wood so you can work with an electric sander for the most part.Screen Shot 2018-09-09 at 10.23.34 AM

I used soft wood filler to do some touch-ups, then finalized using a 220 grit sandpaper to make the surface smooth and ready to paint.Screen Shot 2018-09-09 at 10.25.23 AM

It is a time-consuming job, but depending on the piece you are working on, it is worth every minute.

This was the final result after the chest was ready.

Gray Cedar Chest-1-1

I hope this tutorial was helpful and, as always, let me know in the comments if you have any questions or even other tips for me.

Thanks for reading!


I’m sharing this post on this awesome link parties

To Grandma’s House, We Go!

Sweet Inspiration

Tuesday with a Twist

That DIY Party

Talk of the Town

Penny Pinching Party

Let’s do Some Crafts

Posted by

It all started in the spring of 2013. I realized how tired I was to see my house entirely decorated with IKEA stuff. Nothing against IKEA, but after 12 years, I just needed some change. I wanted stylish, original furniture, but noticed that everything I liked from retail stores was way out of my budget. Thanks to Google, Youtube, and a couple of amazing blogs, I was able to discover and explore the world of furniture refinishing, and it was the beginning of my addiction. I now spend my days rescuing old, dull, unwanted pieces of furniture to give them a fresh look so they can be displayed, used and loved again for many more years to come. Thanks for stopping by.

7 thoughts on “Furniture Prep – How to Fix a Broken Foot

  1. this is a wonderful tutorial and thanks for the accompanying video. Luckily, so far, when I’ve purchased a piece of furniture and a large portion of a foot was missing, the previous owners had been nice enough to put the broken off portion in a drawer. I doubt my luck holds up though and this will definitely come in handy. your tutorials are always so helpful, clear cut, to the point and easy to follow. I appreciate that you don’t include funky loud music in the background or 1/2 hour of extraneous chatter. Everything you include is always helpful information. Thanks again! Oh, and your completed piece is gorgeous!


    1. Thanks so much Christie! I passed up too many beautiful pieces because of missing pieces, until I saw someone else doing this (it was a picture tutorial, not a video). Don’t you love that people share their tricks? I’m all for it and I hope you keep taking advantage and doing beautiful things too!


  2. I love the finished piece. Will you please tell me about the painting techniques that you used on it to get such a unique finish.


  3. Thank you for a wonderful tutorial! I have a 100 year old hope chest that desperately needs repairing and now I’m going to tackle it! I’m going to actually add legs to it like the ones in your video. I make furniture from scratch so I don’t know why I’ve put this off for so long! Thank you for giving me the ideas to complete y project!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s